close

End run around the new council not a good finale

4 min read
article image -

The city of Cape Coral’s on-again, off-again attempt to award a solid waste contract for the collection of garbage, trash and yard waste is on again.

At least as we write this.

Outgoing mayor John Gunter has called a special meeting for next Wednesday, Nov. 18, at 2:30 p.m. to discuss and review again a possible $400 million contract in the wake of protest letters received by the city from two of the three responsive bidders.

That “special meeting” — defined by the city’s Council Agenda Rules of Procedure as “voting meetings called when matters are not scheduled on a regular meeting due to time constraints or urgency and importance of the matter” — must be special, indeed.

It’s set for 90 minutes before three newly elected city council members, and one returning member, are sworn in.

Count us among those who question this last “old council” hurrah, given the project’s history.

Proposals were received from FCC Environmental Services Florida, LLC; Coastal Waste & Recycling of Florida, Inc; and Waste Pro of Florida, Inc., the city’s current provider.

FCC Environmental Services, Florida, LLC received the highest score upon city review. LLC Coastal Waste & Recycling of Florida, Inc, and Waste Pro of Florida, Inc. had some issues with the process and filed protest letters.

As we previously reported, Cape Coral City Council responded to the complaints by referring the letters of protest to the Florida Department of Administrative Hearings on Oct. 7.

We agree this was the proper thing to do as the specter of bid rigging also had been raised. It was an accusation serious enough that former city manager Michael Ilczyszyn recused himself from the meeting before the issue was discussed so as to “protect the organization” and allow staff to know it could speak freely.

Commissioner Keith Long, an attorney and a council member whose presence will be one we will miss come Wednesday, summed things up succinctly with regard to seeking a review from a DOAH administrative law judge.

“These (complaints) move forward to a third-party to review the facts,” Councilmember Long said at the Oct. 7 meeting, adding that the state agency was better suited to conduct such a review. “It comes back to us diluted into a recommended order. It is rooted in logic and legal reasoning.”

“DOAH is insurance. She confirms best in the business. We have nothing to lose,” he added.

A scant two weeks later on Oct. 21, council changed its collective mind and reversed its decision to seek the state review of the bid protests.

The pullback from the DOAH required multiple reconsideration votes with Councilmember Long, and Councilmembers Rachel Kaduk and Jennifer Nelson-Lastra voting against on each.

Pulling this back from the Department of Administrative Hearings was a mistake.

We’re not even sure it was legal.

By referring the complaints, council in essence transferred jurisdiction to the DOAH. With limited exception, state law provides that the referring agency — in this case the city — “shall take no further action” while the review is underway except as a party litigant.

We could not seem to find the “we changed our mind” exception to this rule, but no matter: On Nov. 12 the referral was closed by the DOAH.

Meanwhile, on Nov. 2, Council had already decided it would move forward with its contract award process with FCC Environmental Services Florida, LLC. It set the public hearing for the next regular meeting of Nov. 18.

Here’s where it gets a little interesting.

Since the first meeting of a new council is technically an “organizational meeting,” not a “regular meeting,” Mayor Gunter opted to call the special meeting on the proposed exclusive franchise agreement ahead of it, an effective end-run around the new council.

City Attorney Aleksandr Boksner confirmed his authority to do so.

Now the sitting council that killed the DOAH review wants final say.

It should not have it, “organizational meeting” legalese or not.

With the current contract for waste disposal with Waste Pro not expiring until next September there is urgency, but no emergency, certainly not one that cannot wait 90 minutes for the new council to be seated if there is a need-for-speed aspect we don’t see and council has not seen fit to share via the posting of agenda documents.

The sad thing, for us taxpayers anyway, is that this council is likely leaving a legal quagmire for the next one no matter how the scheduled 11th hour special meeting goes.

We urge Mayor John Gunter to cancel it.

We urge the incoming council members to make this their priority.

We believe they are up to the task.

Breeze editorial