County commission weighs hiring freeze, layoffs in wake of Amendment 3 passage
Lee County commissioners are considering a hiring freeze, layoffs and cuts to departments to start making up for a tax revenue deficit following the passage of Amendment 3.
The deficit is expected to be more than $130 million next year, and somewhere in the range of $200 million in 2028.
Previous estimates by the county had put the lost revenue for the first year a little lower though much higher, at about $240 million, for the second year.
Florida residents voted to increase the homestead property tax exemption for owner-occupied homes. The exemption will raise the exemption from $50,000 of taxable property value to $150,000 in year one, and up to $250,000 in year two.
The increase in the exemption will create a crater in the budgets of Lee County and other local governments, officials said.
Based on preliminary estimates by county officials, there may need to be 15-20% reductions to county departments due to the lost revenue.
The majority of commissioners are not inclined to raise the millage rate at this point though without a clear plan on how the county will come up with the lost revenue, nothing is yet certain.
Lee County Manager Dave Harner proposed a hiring freeze at a workshop of county commissioners on Monday, suggesting the freeze should not extend to several departments due to their revenue sources not being from property taxes. Harner suggested exempting the department of solid waste and utilities, the department of transportation, parks and recreation, and permitting.
Harner also wants to exempt a freeze on hiring as related to EMS and 911 calltakers, though he supports a hiring freeze for other public safety departments.
“That will affect service relatively soon,” Harner said. Harner said the hiring freeze could start immediately or Dec. 1, based on the will of the commissioners.
Harner said the direct service impacts of the hiring freeze could result in longer transit times for buses, as well as limited hours for parks and libraries.
Harner has not yet formulated an estimate on the savings that would result from the hiring freeze though he said it would be substantial. The county currently has about 80 unfilled positions.
About 60% of the county’s budget covers the Lee County Sheriff’s Office, Lee County Clerk’s Office, county court system, Property Appraiser’s Office, Tax Collector’s Office and Supervisor of Elections. Those offices are known as constitutional, in that the officers are required by state law.
While these offices are mandated, the county manager’s office also said there are no limitations as to what can be cut in the budget.
Lee County District 1 Commissioner Kevin Ruane said he wants the county attorney’s office to address the commissioners and explain what the county is required to do and not do based on Amendment 3.
Ruane wants clarity on which jobs are essential and required, and which jobs are not mandatory. Ruane wants to develop a want list and a need list.
“There are going to be on items that we are going to talk to that may be sensitive,” he said.
Lee County employs more than 4,000 workers.
The county has a $3.27 billion budget, with an operating budget of $1.3 billion. Of that amount, about $825 million are departments the county commissioners directly control.
Ruane said the constitutional offices amount to $461 million and he wants the public to understand the impacts and to provide input on the process.
Ruane noted that the county was originally told the budget shortfall between the new revenue numbers if Amendment 3 passed and existing and expected expenses was $240 million.
Ruane said he is more optimistic about being able to fix the revenue loss knowing that it may actually be $211 million in the second year.
“I almost had a heart attack,” he said.
Tuesday’s workshop featured a wide range of different revenue estimates that at one point showed the figure for 2028 to be around $176 million.
Ruane said he has also been given different figures as to what the county’s reserves are. He said the numbers ranged from $75 million to more than $100 million.
“I have been through 13 storms and we have never had enough reserves,” Ruane said.
Ruane said the county should look into going into reserves and exploring a line of credit.
“I will not, under any circumstances, raise our millage rate,” Ruane said. “I want people to get what they deserve.”
Ruane said the county should look into first cutting capital improvements, the Medical Examiner’s Office, capital expenses and other “low-hanging fruit.”
Ruane said he supported a hiring freeze and a freeze on salary raises. Ruane said the county should look into its medical benefits package for workers. He also wants the county to take a look at its procurement practices, which he said has led to the county doing many projects without bidding them out.
Ruane said the county may also have to raise fares for its LeeTran buses.
Lee County Board of County Commissioners Chair David Mulicka said he wants Harner to bring the commissioners options of layoffs, and would like to see a proposed tier of services that would show different levels of service and cuts.
Mulicka said he doesn’t want to raise the millage rate, the property tax that Amendment 3 specifically addresses.
“Everybody wants you to cut the budget, they just don’t want you to cut what they like,” Mulicka said.
Mulicka said the board needed to decide “what can we live without?” Mulicka said “one person’s pork is another person’s livelihood.”
Mulicka said he has been contacted by leaders of local nonprofit organizations worried about a loss of funding for their programs.
Mulicka said the county may have to consider cutting funding for school resource officers working for the Lee County Sheriff’s Office in the School District of Lee County, of which the county currently covers 50%. He noted that while the county’s property tax revenue is taking a major cut from Amendment 3, school taxes weren’t touched.
Lee County District 2 Commissioner Cecil Pendergrass said he supported stopping the county’s voter-approved 20/20 Conservation purchase program which preserves environmentally sensitive land. He hopes perhaps the state can give the county some funds for its conservation fund.
“We are not going to have the money to fund those things,” he said.
Ruane said he supported the elimination of the conservation program, which he estimated could save the county approximately $12 million.
Pendergrass said he doesn’t want cuts to EMS or code enforcement and said he wants Harner to tell the commissioners how the budget issue can be fixed.
Pendergrass expects that projects such as sidewalks and park upgrades that haven’t yet been built yet should be on the table of cuts.
Pendergrass said another impact of Amendment 3 that hasn’t been discussed as much is that Florida could see many more people moving into the county and into the state as the state gets a reputation for being “tax free.” Pendergrass said the more people that move in, the more demand there will be on local services.
“We are going to have more people move down here in the next three years because of that,” Pendergrass said. “That’s just reality.”
Lee County District 4 Commissioner Brian Hamman said affordability issues are key to why Amendment 3 passed.
“We understand the assignment,” Hamman said.
Hamman compared the county’s challenge to a family needing to cut their own spending based on less income. Hamman said the county will have to do what a family under budget constraints would need to do: Sell the family boat, cut out Netflix, find a cheaper cell phone plan and “cutting your own grass.”
Hamman said he wants a line-by-line budget review process that will leave the county with a budget “of necessities,” and then figure out which “luxuries” the county can afford.
Hamman said the county should look at using its reserves to offer employees early retirement packages.
Hamman said he wants a plan from county management to replace the lost tax revenue without raising the millage rate.
District 5 Commissioner Amanda Cochran said the county should ask the state for funding for services the county needs.
To reach NATHAN MAYBERG, please email nmayberg@breezenewspapers.com