Old downtown icon, Big John’s Plaza, sold
New beginning for Cape Coral’s original shopping center & social hub
The first-ever shopping center in Cape Coral has officially been sold.
Big John’s Plaza, which provided early Cape residents with their very own grocery store in the then-fledgling town, hit the market and has been sold by owner Elmer Tabor.
The $10.49 million property along Cape Coral Parkway in the original downtown was sold to an LLC out of Naples.
An iconic location in the city’s history, the first-called Cape Coral Shopping Plaza welcomed residents in 1960 and has been a hub for business ever since, now home to 20 different tenants.
Tabor, a member of one of the city’s pioneer families and owner of the plaza since 1990, said it was simply time to sell the property that’s been in his family since he bought it 36 years ago.
The plaza saw sales in 1968, ’84, and finally to Tabor and his wife Gail in ’90.
Tabor has endless memories over six decades of involvement, such as the Jaycees building a haunted house, the Big John statue, holiday events, city events, and more.
“I could go on and on with stories of things that went on around the center,” Tabor said. “That’s how I know it’s left its legacy.”
As one of the first residents in Cape Coral, Tabor is a man well recognized in the city.
“I can walk around the community with my head held high,” he said. “Sometimes I’ll go into a restaurant and the waitress will come over and tell me another table has picked up my meal. When I go to thank them, they say, ‘Thank you and your family for your contribution to Cape Coral to make it what it is today.’ That’s why I saw my feelings are mixed emotions. The pioneer spirit is still there and will continue, and I’m going to continue being involved in the community.”
Tabor said while he never made it a condition, he “prayed every day” that the eventual buyer of Big John’s was one that would keep the plaza intact, namely because he feels this last City Council “has done an absolute superb job of bulldozing the history of Cape Coral.”
Tabor said, “Big John, unfortunately, is going to be known as the only historic thing left in Cape Coral, because Big John is under private ownership.”
Tabor also shared some good news on the giant statue, as the refurbishing has taken a step in the right direction, and Big John will soon stand downtown tall and proud.
“Big John is still ours, and will always be that way,” he said.
Now 74, Tabor said he wants to “really retire” after wanting to put the plaza on the market four years ago before Hurricane Ian had other plans.
“I have real mixed emotions after 36 years,” Tabor said of the sale being final after it went on the market in mid-April. “After the hurricane did $3.8 million of damage to it, I knew there was no way if anything happened to me that (my family) would be able to take care of it.
“It was really time for the family, while I still could, to go ahead and sell it. It was in great shape after the storm and all the work we put into it.
“It left its own legacy for what it’s done in Cape Coral since day one. There were emotions attached, but I didn’t sell it with emotions. And the new buyers have agreed to continue to support things such as the Holiday Festival of Lights, Art Festival — they’ve agreed to continuing storing the Christmas Tree the Tabor family does every year. Even though they’re not (in Cape Coral), they want to be a part of the community and continue the legacy.”
The deal, brokered by Jack Martin with Century 21 who represented Tabor, was made official this past Tuesday.
Tabor said the 2.02-acre site was purchased as a shopping center, with the new owners retaining all of the current tenants, according to the Cape pioneer.
With its longevity and location touted, Tabor said Big John’s has always been a place businesses have sought to set up shop.
“In real estate, it’s location, location, location,” he said. “This is one of the few communities where you can take a 65-year-old location that might be more valuable today than it was in the early days. Normally downtowns come down and move somewhere new. I don’t think that’ll ever happen to Cape Coral. That location will always be popular.”
Tabor joked that his family has had ties to Big John’s pretty much for forever.
His grandfather, Harold Davis “Andy” Anderson, owned a property on Fort Myers Beach in 1955. When the Rosen brothers started building in the Cape, Anderson decided to venture over and get the skinny from the Rosens.
“The Rosen brothers were land developers, that’s all they wanted to do,” Tabor said. “So, it was going to be a challenge when the got enough developed to bring in businesses. Coincidently, my family was in the grocery business in West Virginia.”
Anderson reached out to Tabor’s father and told him to pack up the kids and move down to this new community that needed a grocery store.
Tabor recalls his father asking how many families were in the Cape at the time, and the dismay when his grandfather said just 13.
Soon enough, the center was under construction in 1959 under a company named Citizens Mutual of Cape Coral, a group of local investors that got together to build the first commercial building, and the Tabors opened the grocery store in June of 1960.
To reach CJ HADDAD, please email cjhaddad@breezenewspapers.com