close

Cape Council awards solid waste contract to FCC Environmental Services

By MEGHAN BRADBURY 7 min read
article image -
The 2024-26 Cape Coral City Council will hold its last session at a special meeting called to discuss the awarding of a new $400 million solid waste contract. PROVIDED

The Cape Coral City Council awarded the municipality’s solid waste collections contract to FCC Environmental Services Florida, LLC during its special meeting Wednesday, minutes before the new elected board was seated.

Outgoing Councilmember Keith Long was the sole member to vote against the 10-year, nearly $400 million contract, saying his no vote was in regards to the process itself.

“This isn’t necessarily what we birthed and followed through for three years,” Long said. “By design, we were brought out of this process early on. It becomes a mess very quickly when talking about hundreds of millions of dollars. We didn’t have involvement until two months ago when all went to hell and then (we were) handed the mess and said deal with it. This isn’t something I see as urgent as being presented. We are leaving here in about 20 minutes and putting $400 (million) plus to the residents – just happened during our term – it’s a no for me.”

Whether it also is a “no” for the incoming council remains to be seen.

Returning Councilmember Jennifer Nelson-Lastra voted yes to keep the new council’s options open.

Nelson-Lastra first made a motion for the continuance of Ordinance 64-26, which was seconded by Long. The motion failed as they were the only two in favor of the motion.

Nelson-Lastra then took a different route to the contract award, already in litigation as the current solid waste provider, Waste Pro, has filed suit alleging the city did not follow its own bidding process.

“Let’s say one of us votes yes knowing that we are voting yes to bring it back to reconsideration,” Nelson-Lastra asked the city attorney.

City Attorney Aleksandr Boksner said in such a situation, a council member who voted on the prevailing side could to bring it back at the next regular meeting on Dec. 2.

Nelson-Lastra then voted yes.

Councilmember Rachel Kaduk, among those who have questioned the process, and the Mayor John Gunter’s decision to call a special meeting before newly elected council members were sworn in, was not present.

Gunter said the 2:30 p.m. special meeting was called after consulting with staff.

The current solid waste contract expires in 10 months, which determined the need for special meeting, he said.

The city’s independent consultant also said the ideal time period for any transfer to a different solid waste provider should be at least 18 months prior to a new contract taking over.

“We are at 10 months now,” Gunter said. “There is an urgency to get this approved to make sure proper transition and enough time for transition. It’s extremely important for residents and business owners to move forward with whoever the next provider would be.”

The ordinance was introduce at the Nov. 2 meeting, with the public hearing scheduled for Nov. 18.

Gunter said the clerk did not specify it for a regular, or special meeting and Gunter said it could not take place at the meeting at which three new members, and one returning member — Nelson-Lastra — would be sworn in. Gunter lost his re-election bid in the primary; council members Long and Bill Steinke did not seek reelection.

“Today’s 4 p.m. meeting is council’s organizational meeting. The organizational meeting is for matters relating to how the council organizes itself and conducts its business,” Gunter said. “That is why we had to take this ordinance in a special meeting. We are not allowed to have general business during organizational meeting as far as council rules are concerned.”

He said the current city council, which has been part of the process the entire time, should consider the ordinance without further delay and for transparency.

Steinke said misleading information was spread about the contract and its timing.

“This is not new business,” he said. “We began discussions and reviews about this topic about six months into my term because of the amount of time that is required to do it properly and put into place. This is something we have been working on for about 3-1/2 years.”

Steinke addressed the added aspect of transfer station that has raised a great deal of concern from the public. He said one of the bidders involved in the conversation, as well as others said, it would be more cost effective if they did not have to go to the Buckingham Road transfer station, but rather have a transfer station locally.

“The trucks wouldn’t have to drive so far to dump and come back and start picking up again,” Steinke said.

The conversation led to asking those biding on the contract to share what it would cost to have a transfer station, for them to originate it and run it, and how much it would save the taxpayers in their solid waste bills.

He said it ended up not being that much of a cost savings if it were to be done based on the bids that were given to the city.

“Your new council would be the council deciding upon if they were to allow a transfer station. There is no requirement in this proposal that they have a transfer station. It will be your new council that will decide whether a transfer station is allowed and where it is allowed,” Steinke said. “The big thing you want to be given to your new council is with your new council already.”

Councilmember Dr. Derrick Donnell said the timing was about ensuring that solid waste continues to collected and that the numbers show that the city will be saving money.

“The vote that I am going to get in trouble for is ensuring our waste is not disrupted at a lower cost,” he said.

Assistant City Manager Mark Mason shared a presentation before the vote for the 10-year franchise agreement with FCC Environmental Services, Florida, LLC who city staff ranked first among the three proposals. Waste Pro of Florida, Inc. ranked second and Coastal Waste and Recycling ranked third.

“This does not include, and has not included, and will not include a solid waste transfer station with this contract,” Mason said.

A Notice of Intent to Award was sent to FCC Environmental Services Florida, LLC on Aug. 6.

The start date is Oct. 1, 2027, and the contract expires on Sept. 30, 2027. There is one five-year renewal.

“It’s an exclusive franchise for solid waste, recyclables, horticulture and bulk collection services to all properties. No other hauler for solid waste can service within Cape Coral during term of agreement,” Mason said.

The current contract with Waste Pro expires Sept. 30, 2027.

Mason said the first year of the new contract calls for a monthly per-residence fee of $18.23, an increase over the existing rate of $3.89.

This would equate to $218.76 per year per residence. The total projected annual assessment is $384.25 per home, including Lee County disposal fees, city operating costs, tax collector costs, and statutory discount recovery.

Mason said the city planned for this and adjusted the assessment on the annual basis, so no large increase would have occurred from three years ago to today.

“The current assessment itself, although it may be less, it won’t exceed that amount when we issue the assessment next year,” he said.

The franchise fee is 8.5% of gross revenue. Mason said the city pays the residential disposal cost with that portion of the contract.

He said the proposer has indicated the franchise period will begin with brand new vehicles, all of which will run on compressed natural gas.

Mason said the most important part of going into a new contract is the transition period. Monthly updates will be given to council on how the transition is going.

The contractor will provide commercial containers for all community events free of charge, provide $50,000 per year for community outreach efforts, and up to four hazardous waste events within city limits.

Mason said the contractor also would provide personnel, equipment, and all services necessary to operate a bulk solid waste drop site located at Northwest 14th Avenue south of Kismet Parkway.

He said the contract will also include real time service verification – taking pictures of every cart they pick up.

To reach MEGHAN BRADBURY, please email mbradbury@breezenewspapers.com