close

Waste Pro files suit against city

Suit alleges city did not follow its own bidding process

By VALARIE HARRING 5 min read
article image -

Saying the city did not follow its own bidding processes, Waste Pro of Florida Inc. has filed a suit against the city of Cape Coral and the vendor city staff ranked first in a three-way contest for a contract to collect the city’s solid waste for the next 10-15 years.

The suit, filed in Circuit County last Wednesday, states that the city’s request for proposals “promised that an evaluation team would score and rank the proposals and recommend a ranking to the City Council; that the City Council would approve the ranking or require public presentations by the top three firms; and that the City would negotiate with the top-ranked firm only after the City Council approved a final ranking.”

Instead, city staff ranked the firms, placing FCC Environmental Services Florida, LLC, which Waste Pro also names in the suit, in the No. 1 spot, the suit alleges.

“The City did not follow that process. Its staff evaluated and ranked the proposals at meetings that were not noticed or open to the public; solicited a second round of pricing that the RFP does not authorize; never issued the notice of ranking that the City’s Code of Ordinances (the “Code”) requires; and, on August 6, 2026, announced an intended award to FCC without any action by the City Council. For months after every statutory exemption had expired, the City refused to produce the public records that would show what was done.”

The suit states that Waste Pro, which has held the contract to collect garbage, recyclables, trash and other forms of solid waste in the city since 2010, formally protested.

The Cape Coral City Council referred that protest, and one from the third vendor, Coastal Waste and Recycling of Florida, Inc., to the state’s Division of Administrative Hearings for review by an administrative law judge.

“Fourteen days later, after the Division had opened a case and assigned an administrative law judge, the City Council purported to rescind the referral and, on the City Attorney’s advice that it was performing an ‘executive function,’ denied the protest without hearing from Waste Pro,” the suit states, adding that the administrative law judge “found that the protest is properly before the Division and has ordered the City to show cause why the case should be closed.”

“The City nonetheless has set Ordinance 64-26, which would approve the ranking, award the RFP to FCC, and approve a franchise agreement with FCC, for adoption at a special meeting at 2:30 p.m. on November 18, 2026, ninety minutes before three newly elected members of the City Council take office,” the suit states.

The DOAH filing has since been closed.

Wednesday’s special meeting to consider the awarding of the solid waste contract to FCC Environmental Services was called by outgoing Mayor John Gunter. The swearing in of the incoming council, with three new and one returning member, is set for 4 p.m.

Saying the intended bid award is invalid and that the denial of its protest of the process without a hearing violates city code and possibly state Sunshine Laws, Waste Pro is seeking an injunction to stay the process and so stop the awarding of a contract.

Waste Pro details its the basis allegations in the remaining 848 pages of its 850-page suit, including evidentiary attachments, saying, “Waste Pro will suffer irreparable harm, and has no adequate remedy at law, unless the RFP procurement and contract award process, including the approval, execution, or performance of a franchise agreement with FCC, is stayed while the protests are pending.”

The contract as per the RFP issued by the city, would be for 10 years beginning at the start of Fiscal Year ’28 — which begins Oct. 1, 2027 — and expiring on Sept. 30, 2037. The contract includes the option to renew for one five-year additional term under the same terms and conditions as the initial period.

The city has not provided a total value number on the FCC Environmental Services Florida proposal but has used the number $400 million in public discussions.

As listed in the suit, Waste Pro outlines its damages as “As a direct and proximate result, Waste Pro has suffered damages, including (a) the loss of a fair opportunity to compete for the franchise, measured, to the extent the evidence permits, by the profits Waste Pro would have earned over the initial term and extension; (b) the costs of preparing its proposal and its response to the request for best and final offers; (c) the costs of its protest, including the $5,000 protest bond; and (d) the loss of goodwill and the costs of demobilizing its Cape Coral operations that will follow its displacement as the City’s franchise contractor.”

In response to a request for comment, city officials said the city does not comment on pending litigation.

The Nov. 18 special meeting will be held in City Council chambers, 1015 Cultural Park Blvd.

The 2:30 p.m. meeting is open to the public as is the regular meeting to follow at 4 p.m.

To reach VALARIE HARRING, please email vharring@breezenewspapers.com